Portable Recorder Battery Life Test Results
Rather than rely solely on manufacturer's claims, we wanted to find out for ourselves just how long batteries may last in the portable recorders we sell. Here's what we found. Your mileage may vary, of course.
1st Place |
2nd Place |
3rd Place |
|
|
|
Sony PCM-M10 43.0 hours |
Sony PCM-D50 25.5 hours |
Olympus LS-11 19.2 hours |
|
4th Place |
5th Place |
6th Place |
|
|
|
Olympus LS-10 8.5 hours |
Tascam DR-07 7.5 hours |
Marantz PMD620 6.4 hours |
|
7th Place |
8th Place |
9th Place |
|
|
|
Zoom H2 6.3 hours |
Marantz PMD661 5.8 hours |
Tascam DR-1 5.8 hours |
|
10th Place |
11th Place |
12th Place |
|
|
|
Edirol R-09HR 5.3 hours |
M-Audio MicroTrack II 4.8 hours |
Zoom H4n 4.4 hours (7.7 hours stamina) |
13th Place |
14th Place |
15th Place |
|
|
|
Sony PCM-D1 4.0 hours |
Korg MR-1 2.8 hours |
Zoom Q3 1.6 hours (movie mode) 2.6 hours (audio-only) |
16th Place |
|
|
Tascam DR-100 1.3 hours (AA) 5.7 hours (BP-L2) |
|
|
|
How We Did the Battery Life Contest
First, we fully charged the Korg MR-1, MicroTrack II, and Tascam DR-1 and loaded the other recorders with Duracell Coppertop AA batteries - the kind you can find in almost any US retail store.
Second, to avoid the possibility of running out of memory before running out of power, we set all the units (except the Korg, the Sony D50 and the Sony D1) to record in MP3 format at 128 kbps.
The Sony D50 and D1 units were set at 16-bit/22.05 kHz wav files (they don't record mp3s). The Korg MR-1 was set at 16-bit 44.1kHz wav files.
Third, we pressed "record" on each unit and left them on until they ran out of power. The times noted are the total lengths of the resulting files.
Even after giving a "low battery" warning, each recorder (except the Zoom H2, which fully drained its batteries) retained approximately 30 minutes in reserve power.
Most impressive was the phenomenal performance of the Sony PCM-M10. That 43.0 hours is not a typographical error. We literally started it on a Saturday night and it kept going until late Monday afternoon. If battery life is a big concern for you, the Sony PCM-M10 seems to be the clear choice, with the Sony PCM-D50 and the Olympus LS-11 a distant second and third.
|